|

|
This page contains reviews of and links to online art supply
stores. Criteria include ease of navigation, ease of ordering,
site design, and pricing.
This is a work in progress... your comments must be the heart
of this page. Coming also is a more comprehensive comparative
shopping basket. And we will cover online framers.
Mariana Sparre is researching this...she needs your feedback
What has your experience been with the sites. Do they have
materials in stock, do they ship promptly, how about back
orders, returns, customer service, etc.
|
|
first
visit to Artspan?
We are artists; each of us has his/her own website &
URL. The sites are used in our own promotion, but can also
be reached through artspan.com using the Artspan search
functions.
Set-up of the sites is free and the monthly hosting fee
is very low. Included is promotional help and more.
It
is our goal to be the Internet resource for
collectors, galleries, & consultants.
We are on our way. Artspan is one of the most visited art
sites.
|
art
supplies
www.artresource.com
Overview:
Emphasis is on the hobbyist and student. There is not a
lot of variety in terms of brands and items for the fine
artist. On the plus side, the site is well organized and
easy to get around.
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: there are only 2 brands, Winsor &
Newton and Grumbacher.
2. Artist brushes: we found Winsor & Newton and then
a drop into a couple of low end brands.
Art
supplies prices. Here are prices for one line of paints,
Winsor & Newton (series 1- 5) $4.81, 6.58, 16.23, 26.08,
40.42. Brushes: Winton filbert #4 is $ 5.60. These are good
prices and representative of other prices on the site. Shipping
is UPS and charge is straight shipping charge. There does
not appear to be extra handling fee. Returns: good system,
they will send return authorization and shipping label.
All you have to do is call UPS for pickup.
Last
Word.... beware Paint by Numbers section, you
could get hooked…serious art contenders will instead want
to consider a Bob Ross painting set.
|
|
www.jerryscatalog.com
Overview:
We had a little trouble figuring out what the site was about.
First impression was cartooney, folksy and forced. However,
the site is easy to navigate. Good selection of artist materials,
including considerable variety in fine art brands.
Art
Supply Specifics(2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: W&N, Rembrandt, Blockx, Shiva, Lukas,
Maimeri, Permalba, Rembrandt,
Van Gogh and more.
2. Artist brushes: Simmons, Isabeym Manet Raphael, Grumbacher,
Winsor & Newton, etc.
Art supplies prices. Here are prices for Winsor & Newton,
again series 1- 5: $4.67, 6.56, 16.14, 25.94, 40.17. Filbert
#4 brush by Simmons was only $4.29. Altogether, very reasonable
prices and great selection. However, shipping charges appear
to be actual cost + handling charge. This does add at least
a couple or more dollars to the total.
Finally... the site grew on us: good inventory. And
the logo kinda grew on us too...the artiste (lil'
Jerry) with the beret. And sometimes without the beret...
looked a little like a teletubby.
|
www.artstores.com
Overview:
"Real Supplies. Real Artists." It's cheerful and colorful,
and a bit of a yawn. Difficult to get off the homepage also.
The nav bar doesn't appear until you get to one of the interior
pages. So, our advice: hit any of the links to get off the
homepage. Once you do that, you will be ok until you begin
to order. There is an unnecessary step in ordering that
results in lost time. You must first click on the item name,
then you will get a pop-up screen where you add the item
to your shopping cart. Surprisingly clunky procedure.
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: limited selection. W&N, Rowney,
and a generic brand that doesn't appear available online.
2. Artist brushes: again limited selection.
Art
supplies prices. Here again are prices for Winsor &
Newton (series 1- 5) $5.04- 42.33. Brushes: Winton filbert
#4 is $ 5.95.
Other prices also somewhere in the middle.
Shipping is UPS and charge seems pretty much straight shipping
charge.
All
in all...For a retail operation with a strong urban
presence, a surprising lack of any kind of urban edge. But
they do have a nice selection of crafts and kids stuff.
|
|
www.meininger.com
Overview:There
are 4 sections: Online Catalogue, Education Center, Info
Center and the About the Meiningers sections (family biz
since 1881, nice to know). But there is really only 1 section
and 1 page, and that page is called "Product Directory."
Yes, its the "put everything on one page" philosophy
which we will subscribe to once everyone has high speed
access. Until then its a longish wait for that big page
to open (and for some of the other pages also...they may
need to upgrade their server). Ordering seems to go fairly
smoothly
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: W&N, Gamblin, Maimeri.
2. Artist brushes: limited.
Art
supplies prices. Here again are prices for Winsor &
Newton (series 1- 5) $4.99 - 41.89.
Other prices are also just ok.
Shipping is UPS and there is a little extra in there for
handling ($8.95 for orders up to $50)
Sincerely
yours.... they have 2 stores in Colorado, seem like
nice folks, but the site could use a little attention.
|
www.cheapjoes.com
Overview:
Nice, clean site (and big, a lot of stuff). Pages load fast.
Really easy to navigate. Secret is in the Navigation bars
at the bottom and to the left. They will take you where
you need to go and do it quickly. You can order stuff and
then quickly add something else from another category. Good
keyword search also, very useful. Quick checkout, no hassles.
Also should mention the inventory buttons. Red (out of stock),
green (in stock)and yellow (beginning to run short)will
tell you the status of the item being ordered.
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: nice selection: 8 brands
2. Artist brushes: good selection of both quality and low
end brushes.
Art
supplies prices. Here again are prices for Winsor &
Newton oil paints (series 1- 5) $4.40-36.10. Brushes: Simmons
filbert #4 is $3.80.
Other prices also very good.
Shipping is UPS and charge is a bit over the average ($9.99
for below $35 orders), but this is not an important factor
as low prices on art materials more than compensate
Soup
to Nuts...Very complete site, great inventory, you can
get what you want and at the right price. Also like their
catalogue, the kind of reference you will keep around. And
check out the workshops.
|
|
www.pearlpaint.com
Overview:
The icon approach, just click through and you will be where
you want to be (in theory). Seems like it should work. And
it does, as long as your order is not a large one. But to
order a number of varied items, extra steps are necessary.
And moving around within the site is difficult. The site
needs a nav bar or two. And pages are not that interesting
to look at either. Mediocre design on all counts.
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: selection is great, among the best,
lots to choose from
2. Artist brushes: Somewhat lesser selection, but still
more than adequate
Art
supplies prices. Winsor & Newton artist oil paints (series
1- 5) $6.02 - 50.61.
Other prices are also at the top of the range.
And they are consistent. Shipping prices are also high.
Orders under $50 have a handling charge of $4.95 in addition
to shipping charge.
Once
upon a time...Pearl was originally the store
for real artists with their store on Canal Street in New
York. Emphasis now seems to be on mall stores.
|
www.dickblick.com
Overview:
A beast of a site, very complete, with pictures, colors,
varied search functions, everything. The search functions
include keywords, tabs, departments, and index, a number
of different solutions to whatever search you may want to
undertake. Also information on products as text on page
and as pop-up pages.
Only problem comes from completeness of offering, takes
a while to get around the site and select items for the
shopping cart. And in some of the pages, individual items
(i.e. different paints from 1 manufacturer) appear as a
long list at the bottom of page and take forever to load.
Dick Blick would do better to break that down into smaller
morsels. Still, more than just the beast, it is one of the
best.
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: nice selection: the most brands
2.Artist brushes: great selection of brushes.
Art
supplies prices. Winsor & Newton oil paints (series
1- 5) $4.39-36.99. Other pricing is also good but not at
the real low end.
Shipping is USPS or FedEx and charge is reasonable. All
orders over $200, shipping is free.
Serious
business....They
have a substantial bricks and mortar presence with 34 stores
mostly in the Midwest U.S. This has not stopped them from
making a real commitment to online sales.
|
|
www.misterart.com
Overview:
Impressive site. They got it right. Well thought out, intuitive,
and good search functions. Also, pages load fast: they avoided
the mistake of making pages too big. They have added user
reviews of the products. They
offer something they call the V.I.P. membership for $25/year.
They are, however, a little unclear on the specifics but
it seems to be afair deal and to deliver on their promise
that you willl "receive an extra discount off of the
already low everyday prices listed in our online store."
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints:very good selection
2.Artist brushes: the best of the online sites.
Art
supplies prices. Winsor & Newton oil paints (series
1- 5) $5.68-47.72. This was second highest of the sites
we have looked at and we were suprised. Other items we looked
at did not appear to be quite so pricey.
Shipping is UPS Ground or other as you specify. Shipping
charge is reasonable.
Interesting
soiree....Mr Coffee meets Mr Art.
By the way, Mr Art is a virtual dude. (no bricks and mortar).
|
www.dixieart.com
Overview: A different look. An art site with a topping of
Louisiana hot sauce site. However, the site is"currently
being redesigned" Good short product descriptions and
the pages load quickly. Ordering is straightforward. Main
page is for fine arts, but there are other major sections
devoted to exotic stuff like "tatoos and body art."
Art
Supply Specifics (2 representative areas):
1. Artist oil paints: limited
2. Artist brushes: again, limited.
Art
supplies prices. Winsor & Newton oil paints (series
1- 5) $4.30-36.15. Makes them the low price winner, at least
on this item.
Brushes and other items also on the low side.
Surprise.....this
site was a bit of a sleeper, ended scoring fairly well in
most areas.
|
|
www.utrecht.com
Overview:
Nav bar on the left covers all categories of art materials
on the site, soup to nuts. The site is easy to get around,
not cluttered. Ordering procedure is simple and quick.
Art
Supply Specifics: Real attraction is combination of Utrecht/
generic and a few top brands (i.e. Grumbachewr, W&N,
Rembrandt along with Utrecht oil paints or Classen and Utrecht
linen canvas). Utrecht paints and brushes are of reasonably
good quality . Certainly with less critical supplies, they
are very acceptable alternative, but perhaps not at top
end (i.e. yellow ochre no problem, but for something like
a cadmium red go for the W&N or Rembrandt). Ditto with
other materials.
Art
supplies prices. Winsor & Newton oil paints (series
1- 5) $4.99-42.29. Not low or high cost leaders. But if
you combine Utrecht products with better brands, you will
do ok.
Experience
counts....Their very considerable experience in retail
and mail order show in the design of this site. And, no
Paint by Numbers! You will not find Utrecht at the mall.
|
www.flaxart.com
Overview:
S.F.-based operation, not to be confused with Sam Flax in
New York or other Flaxes around the country (family got
separated). Also not to be confused with a fine arts supplies
retailer. We could not find oil paints except for introductory
set. Either they don't sell them or the site won't let you
find them. Seem to have a smattering of products in a lot
of areas but not depth and no real commitment to fine art.
The
look of the site is very clean, nice though unoriginal design
and no compelling reason to linger or to buy.
|
|
www.triangleart.com
Overview:
The new art. Their heart seems to be with the corporate
customer. There are a lot of imaging services. They do have
traditional fine arts products, but this is not a main feature
of the site. In fact, we found a number of dead art supplies
links that went nowhere. Other links brought us back to
Mr. Art. Appears to be a connection there.
Another site with a nice clean design look, but their focus
seems elsewhere.
|
|
|
|
|